Jake hesitated and then did so, Matthew and Paul stared for a moment but then wordless communication seemed to pass between them and Jake and they returned to their game. "You just had an emotional response, Father." Jake said. "And yet you say we are but machines?"
"I can have an emotional response to a painting of a scene, but that does not mean the painting is in any way really alive." Father Thomas said, the arguments leaping naturally to his tongue.
"And would you say that a painting has no soul?" Jake asked.
Father Thomas hesitated at the turn of argument. The opposition's stances cared little for the soul in its arguments. "An object cannot have a soul." He said. "To believe otherwise is the parable of the Golden Calf."
"Then what is intrinsic to a painting that makes it more than just spilled paint?" Jake asked. "And what separates it from the Golden Calf?"
Father Thomas paused again, considering. "I would say that any work of art contains a bit of the divine spark within it, the act of creation passed along and held suspended in that work for as long as it endures. The Golden Calf represents the worship of that result, of thinking that man's creation can surpass god's."
"Can't it?" Jake asked.
"What?"
"You are not an uneducated literal fundamentalist." Jake said and took another sip of his beer. Father Thomas wondered if it had any effect on his artificial body chemistry. "You do not think that the world was created in 7 days . . ."
"Six." Father Thomas said by rote. "On the seventh he rested."
"Hair splitting does not advance a debate." Jake said. "You do not think the world was created in six days, and I would venture that you don't believe evolution is a myth."
"I believe god's hand was in it." Father Thomas ventured, but did not argue. An accomplished debater did not argue for the sake of argument, he waited until he could discern the direction of the argument.
Jake nodded and switched direction. "Why do you believe in evolution?"
"Science." Father Thomas said. "Evidence."
"Why do you believe in it with your spirit, not your mind?"

Buy My Book